Pine Island Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

Pine Island Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

Welcome to Pine Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Lee County, Florida. This charming non-gated community offers a unique blend of serene living and vibrant local culture, making it the perfect place to call home.

Pine Island is renowned for its stunning natural beauty, featuring lush landscapes and breathtaking waterfront views that are sure to captivate any nature lover. The community is surrounded by picturesque mangroves and pristine waters, inviting residents to explore a variety of outdoor activities, from kayaking and fishing to leisurely strolls along the scenic trails.

The homes in Pine Island boast a delightful array of architectural styles, each designed to harmonize with the enchanting surroundings. With spacious layouts and modern amenities, these residences provide the perfect backdrop for both relaxation and entertaining. Whether you’re looking for a cozy bungalow or a larger family home, Pine Island has something to suit every lifestyle.

Living in Pine Island means embracing a laid-back lifestyle while still being close to the vibrant attractions of Lee County. Enjoy fresh seafood at local restaurants, engage with friendly neighbors at community events, or take advantage of the nearby beaches for a day of sun and surf.

Pine Island is more than just a place to live; it’s a community where you can create lasting memories and enjoy the beauty of Florida living. Discover the charm of Pine Island and find your dream home in this idyllic setting today!

Newest Pine Island Homes with Non-Gated Community Type

$325,198
2026031044 MLS
Create your private retreat area. Attention, Nature conservators, Land Bankers, Land mitigation asset comptrollers. Almost 10 acres of Pristine Virgin Pine Island acres near open water on offer for your consideration.(in the Master's Landing vicinity) Address not yet determined Approximate measurement is as follows:328' x 1369' x 328' x1368'

TBD Masters Landing Drive, Other
$599,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 2026029862 MLS
Live the Pine Island Waterfront Lifestyle! Escape to this beautifully remodeled gulf-access stilt home where every upgrade is already done and every day feels like vacation. This turnkey retreat blends modern comfort with the laid-back charm of island living—just bring your clothes and a toothbrush and start enjoying the water. A Boater’s Paradise as you step outside onto your 2024 captain’s-walk dock, complete with a 13,000 lb. boat lift and a convenient fish cleaning station. Launch straight into Matlacha Pass with no bridges—just open water, world-class fishing, and endless boating adventures right from your backyard. Fresh, Modern, and Move-In Ready Inside, the home shines with a full 2023 remodel to include: New kitchen and appliances, new laminate flooring installed over an added ¾" plywood reinforcement for a solid floor. New roof, hot water heater, replumb, and updated electric panel. Clean, bright spaces designed for comfort and easy coastal Island living at its best! Sip your morning coffee with the breeze on the balcony, spend afternoons on the water, and unwind with sunset views only Pine Island can offer. Whether you’re seeking a seasonal escape or a full-time waterfront lifestyle, this home delivers effortless living in one of Southwest Florida’s most peaceful boating communities.

5375 Serenity Cove, Bokeelia
$342,423
2026027336 MLS
Treasure Hunt! 10+ Pristine Virgin Pine Island acres near open water on offer for your consideration in the Master's Landing vicinity. The address is not yet determined. The approximate measurement is as follows: 332' X 1367 (10+acres)'. Walk past the corner of Masters Landing Dr. Go east of Pirate Landing Ln there is a paper road once at the corner of those two roads you walk about 573 feet and you will be at the SW corner of this unamed parcel which is situated to the east of mls#2026025968 and shares a property line with it. Together these contigous parcels comprise a 27+ acre opportunity. Attention, Nature conservators, Land Bankers, Land mitigation asset comptrollers anyone looking to build a unique estate.

TBD Masters landing Drive, St James City
$39,900
2026025676 MLS
Discover the possibilities on beautiful Pine Island with this oversized approximately ½-acre homesite tucked away at the end of a quiet road. Offering added privacy and plenty of space to design your ideal island retreat, this property provides a rare opportunity to enjoy the laid-back lifestyle that makes Bokeelia so desirable. Pine Island Water and electric service are available, making the path to building even more convenient. Surrounded by the natural beauty, fishing, boating, and small-town charm of Pine Island, yet just a short drive to local restaurants, marinas, and everyday conveniences, this is the perfect location for your future home or investment property. Don't miss your chance to own a spacious piece of Southwest Florida paradise.

6198 Hodges Drive, Bokeelia
$30,000
2026023824 MLS
Zoning- RSA

Papaya Avenue, Bokeelia
$195,000
2026020209 MLS
Waterfront Gulf Access Lot – St. James City, Pine Island Build your dream waterfront home on this exceptional gulf-access lot in St. James City with no HOA restrictions. This property features a newer 52-foot concrete seawall and cap built by Honc Marine Construction, ideal for larger vessels, sailboats, and serious boaters. Enjoy one-turn access to the Intracoastal Waterway and minutes by boat to Sanibel, Captiva, and Fort Myers Beach, offering some of the best boating, fishing, and island hopping in Southwest Florida. A brand-new thick reinforced concrete pad is already in place, ready for a stilt home or mobile/modular build. City water and sewer are available (no well or septic needed), saving thousands in construction costs. A modular home floor plan is included for buyers looking to fast-track their build. This lot was previously the site of a highly profitable Airbnb rental, demonstrating strong income potential for short-term rental investors. The parcel is on the larger side for this neighborhood, offering extra space for parking, storage, outdoor living, or future expansion. No HOA, no deed restrictions, and endless possibilities!

3814 Dewberry Lane, St James City
$497,500
2026020078 MLS
SELLER FINANCING AVAILABLE!!! Your shortcut to island living starts here. Welcome to your private slice of paradise on Pine Island. Set on 2.5 acres, this property is already prepped and packed with opportunity the clearing and elevation is done, so you can skip the heavy lifting and jump straight into bringing your vision to life. Tucked away at the very end of a quiet dirt road, this peaceful setting is surrounded by other large parcels, offering both privacy and room to grow. A serene salt water pond borders the west side, adding a natural focal point and tranquil views. Zoned agricultural, this land is incredibly versatile design your dream homestead, start that boutique farm or nursery, or create a private retreat complete with a custom home, pool, and barn. With approximately 200 palm trees already on the ground included in the sale (standing palms do not convey), you’ve got a head start on landscaping or business potential. What truly sets this property apart are two brand-new wooden covered structures beautifully built and perfect for hosting gatherings, parties, family reunions, or even creating a unique event space. Whether you're entertaining under the island breeze or planning something bigger, the setup is already here. Utilities are already in place, with electric on site and a well. fed irrigation system covering the entire property ideal for maintaining lush greenery year round. Life on Pine Island is all about slowing down and soaking it in. Known for its laid-back charm, the island offers scenic bike paths, a local K–5 school, fresh-caught seafood, and endless kayaking opportunities. Surrounded by Gulf waters, you’ll also have access to some of the best shallow water fishing in the world. Whether you're looking to build, invest, or create something truly unique this property delivers the space, setting, and flexibility to make it happen.

12242 Eagles Nest Drive, Bokeelia
$44,900
2026019640 MLS
Calling all anglers, boaters, and lovers of the outdoors—this is your chance to claim your own slice of island living. Situated on **½ acre in unincorporated Bokeelia**, this property offers an incredible opportunity to build or invest in one of Southwest Florida’s most naturally beautiful and peaceful communities. Bokeelia is known for its quiet, laid-back lifestyle and abundant wildlife, offering a true escape while still being within reach of **Cape Coral, Fort Myers, and Punta Gorda**. Despite its secluded feel, you're just a short drive to airports, beaches, shopping, and dining. Take a drive out and experience it for yourself—you may find there’s no reason to leave the island once you arrive. Located at the northern tip of Pine Island, Bokeelia is surrounded by water, with easy access to **Pine Island Sound, Charlotte Harbor, and Matlacha Pass**—making it a dream location for boating and world-class fishing enthusiasts. Enjoy **southern exposure** and a setting filled with native palms and natural beauty. The lot will require some clearing, along with installation of a well and septic system, giving you the flexibility to design and build exactly what you envision. Let's go, what are you waiting for?

5599 Royal Okley Lane, Bokeelia
$1,350,000
2026018515 MLS
Prime opportunity in the heart of Bokeelia (Pine Island)!! This 4.78 Acre commercial parcel offers exceptional visibility and accessibility with over 300 ft. of frontage along Pine Island Rd. - one of the area's main thoroughfares. Zoned CC , CG, and CT , with a portion designated to TFC-2, this versatile property allows for a wide range of Commercial and mixed-use opportunities. Whether your looking to establish retail, office, service-oriented businesses, or a combination project, the zoning flexibility provides a strong foundation for your vision. Even better, Site plans have already been approved through Lee County for OPEN STORAGE BUSINESS , saving valuable time and expense-making this property truly SHOVEL--READY FOR DEVELOPMENT! DON'T MISS THIS RARE CHANCE TO SECURE A HIGH - VISIBILITY COMMERCIAL SITE IN A GROWING AREA. CALL TODAY FOR MORE INFORMATION !!

5361 Pine Island Road NW, Bokeelia
$524,500
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 226014250 MLS
Welcome to this beautifully maintained and move-in-ready home that perfectly blends comfort, style, and convenience. Nestled in the private community of Isle of Pines, this property offers an inviting open-concept layout filled with natural light, ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious kitchen features modern appliances, a gas stove, ample cabinetry, two pantries and a generous island that flows seamlessly into the living and dining areas. The oversized primary suite provides a relaxing retreat with a well-appointed en-suite complete with soaking tub, a large tiled shower, his and hers walk-in closets and sliding doors to a private lanai. Two additional bedrooms are perfect for guests, each with their own en suite and large closets. Step outside to enjoy the heated pool and private clubhouse with pool table, and a bonus guest apartment for overflow company. This community has a private waste water system, so you’ll never have to worry about a septic. With thoughtful upgrades throughout, and pride of ownership evident in every detail, this home truly stands out. Walk to nearby Pineland Marina and Alden Pines Golf Course, or enjoy a five star dinner at the world renowned Tarpon Lodge, right in your back yard! A brand new outdoor lift and maintenance free landscaping complete this beautiful property .This home sustained no damage or flooding from any of the recent storms. Don’t miss your opportunity to make this exceptional island home your own—schedule your showing today! Motivated Seller!! New asking price Now $524500

7655 Myrsine Circle, Bokeelia
$35,000
2026002921 MLS
This vacant land located in unincorporated Bokeelia on Pine Island. This parcel offers a quiet setting with no HOA and no city restrictions, providing flexibility for future use or development. Situated in a peaceful residential area with easy access to local amenities, fishing, boating, and the natural beauty Pine Island is known for. The adjacent home (MLS #2026018410) and the lot (MLS #2026002820) next to that home are also available for purchase, offering a unique opportunity to assemble multiple parcels totaling over 1.6 acres. Enjoy the laid-back island lifestyle while still being within driving distance to shopping, dining, and beaches. Buyer to verify zoning, utilities, and building requirements.

6451 Allen Park Drive, Bokeelia
$32,500
2026001871 MLS
Pine Island vacant lot ready for you to experience true island living! Centrally located on the island, this property offers convenient access to St. James City to the south and Bokeelia to the north, known for its local fruit stands, fishing, and laidback coastal charm. Enjoy the relaxed Pine Island lifestyle with nearby marinas, waterfront dining, and natural beauty all around perfect for building your island retreat or full-time residence.

5500 Birdsong Lane, Bokeelia
Start Your Search